Discover the Unique Experience of Cold Case Ice Cream: More Than Dessert

The Sweet Mystery Behind Cold Case Ice Cream

Cold Case Ice Cream is not just a frozen treat; it's an adventure waiting to unfold in your kitchen. Hailing from Utah, this innovative company combines high-butterfat flavors with an intriguing mystery game delivered directly to your doorstep. CEO Josh Butt leads the charge in pushing the boundaries of ice cream, transforming how we engage with this classic dessert.

Decadent Flavors Like You've Never Experienced

At Cold Case Ice Cream, the emphasis on quality speaks volumes. Using a maximum overrun of 50 percent—compared to the industry norm of 100 percent—each pint promises a rich and creamy texture that melts perfectly in your mouth. Butt explains, "Our ice cream delivers a custard-like enjoyment without all the eggs." This commitment to quality culminates in flavors that tantalize the taste buds. With unique offerings like Illegal Fireworks—a cake batter base enhanced with popping candy—and America’s Most Wanted, which boasts goat cheese and blackberry jam, there is a flavor to satiate every craving.

Innovative Ice Cream with a Twist of Fun

What sets Cold Case Ice Cream apart is not just taste, but also the playful approach to the product. Each order includes a golden shovel spoon and incident reports that relate to the flavors. Consumers are encouraged to engage in a mystery game while savoring their treats, a concept that combines indulgence with problem-solving. As Butt puts it, “We just love the concept of listening to your favorite true crime podcast or watching a documentary tied to something delicious.” This family-friendly mystery adds an element of excitement to ice cream consumption that has never been explored before.

A Commitment to Freshness and Creativity

Cold Case prides itself on freshness, with add-ins prepared from scratch the same day they are incorporated into the ice cream. For example, the cake used in the flavor Better than Sex is baked that morning and mixed into the ice cream by lunchtime. This attention to detail ensures that every spoonful is packed with flavor and freshness, a testament to the dedication Cold Case has towards its customers.

Preparing for a National Expansion

As demand continues to grow across the U.S. through platforms like DoorDash, Cold Case is preparing to scale up its operations. A new production facility in Springville, Utah, is in progress, allowing for automation that will help maintain the quality and integrity of their premium ice cream. “Demand is going up almost exponentially,” Butt notes, emphasizing the importance of consistent quality as they expand their reach.

Community Engagement and Future Innovations

Cold Case doesn’t just serve ice cream; they aim to strengthen community bonds through weekly innovation sessions where employees brainstorm new flavors. Anticipating the holiday season, Butt teased upcoming offerings like Slay Ride and Gingerbread Manslaughter, ensuring that there’s always something humorous and delicious on the horizon.

As the company grows, the heartwarming stories behind its creation and flavors will continue to resonate with customers, transforming an ordinary treat into an extraordinary experience. The love for food, creativity, and fun is at the core of Cold Case Ice Cream, keeping consumers eagerly engaged with every bite.